Private

FS 3.173

Visions and conflicts in socio-ecological transformation in mountain territories

Please log in to add items to your favorites.

Details

  • Full Title

    FS 3.173: Competiting visions of socio-ecological transformations in mountain territories : analyzing the role of conflicts
  • Scheduled

    TBA
  • Location

    TBA
  • Assigned to Synthesis Workshop

    ---
  • Thematic Focus

    Equality, Policy, Socio-Ecology
  • Keywords

    territory, socio-ecological transformation, visions, conflicts, transdisciplinarity

Description

Territorial dynamics going along with socio-ecological transformation processes are often caused by the lack of shared visions concerning the present and desired future. The co-existence of antagonistic visions and narratives even leads to conflicts among the population when facing situations of crisis. This session aims to examine the role of the multiple visions, imaginaries and underlying conflicts in shaping socio-ecological transformations in mountain territories. It raises the following questions: -How do ongoing territorial dynamics inform about cooperation or confrontation among different social groups in socio-ecological transformations? -What role do confronting visions and conflicts play in socio-ecological transformations? -Which practices and conventions are subject to negotiations in such conflicts and which remain unquestioned? -How to take into account and overcome existing power relations ? -What role play ideas of democracy, justice and inclusiveness in these conflicts and visions?

The session also aims to explore the field research methods, that allow researchers to grasp such dynamics and to accompany socio-ecological transformations. We are particularly interested in sharing experiences in terms of transdisciplinary, participative research and reflexive assessment and would like to discuss on:

  • How do we include the diversity of visions in territorial transformations in our research designs?
  • How to ensure an horizontal, participative, just, inclusive dialogue among actors?
  • What potential do transdisciplinary approaches provide to co-create a shared vision and work collectively towards it?
  • What should be the posture(s) of researchers?

Submitted Abstracts

ID: 3.9006

Solving ordinary problems with extraordinary events? Mega-events and socio-spatial dynamics in the Alps: the case study of Milano-Cortina 2026 Winter Olympics

Caterina Stocchi

Abstract/Description

This study aims to advance ongoing debates on the effects of mega events by exploring the socio-spatial dynamics of the Winter Olympic Games (WOG) in the Alps, how these areas react to these events and the challenges they will face in the post-Olympic scenario. The research is set in the Boite Valley, a mountain community in the Italian Alps that will host the 2026 WOG. Data was collected through interviews, photography and document analysis. Lefebvre’s spatial triad was used as a critical lens to analyse these dynamics. The research understands mega-events as a magnifying glass of already existing local dynamics while accelerating and reproducing global dynamics such as rapid urbanization, commercialization and capital-led development. The study revealed the ‘extraordinary’ transformation of the mega-events overlapping with the ‘ordinary’ transformation of mountain areas. The paper shows that the redevelopment projects required to host the Olympics mismatch the needs of the hosting communities and overlook potentially more effective efforts that address present needs for these areas.

ID: 3.9699

Interdependencies and conflicts between territorialities in sustainable agri-food transformations. Examples from the Bauges and Galaure territoires.

Carine Pachoud

Abstract/Description

Sustainability transformations are spatially situated and dependent on the contexts in which they take place. The French concept of territoire makes it possible to analyze, situate and politicize transformation processes more systematically, paying attention to relations of interdependence and conflict between groups. In this study, we use the multidimensional conceptual framework of territorial transformations (Pachoud et al., 2022), to analyze the transformation dynamics of agri-food systems in the Coeur des Bauges and the Galaure valley, in France. Through a qualitative analysis, the territorial approach first enabled to describe the different dominant and alternative territorialities linked to the agri-food system in the two territoires studied, in their material, ideal and institutional dimensions. In addition, the territorial approach highlighted the interdependent relationships between the different groups, as well as the tensions and conflicts underlying the different power relationships. The comparative analysis demonstrated the ability of different groups to develop interdependency relationships to ensure food production in the territoires and to deal with conflict situations, linked to land sharing and divergent imaginaries. Such interactions between the different groups allow learning and sustainable transformations of agriculture and food.

ID: 3.9776

Stakeholders’ perceptions of environmental inequities related to ecosystem services: insights from the Maurienne Valley (France)

Zoé Pelta
Lavorel, Sandra; Vallet, Améline

Abstract/Description

The distribution of ecosystem services (ES) benefits among actors depends not only on landscape configuration but also on governance, institutions, processes, and structures that regulate access to and allocation of ES.
Different types of inequities have been highlighted by environmental justice scholars, with distributive – and, to a lesser extent, procedural – inequities receiving more attention than recognition. Stakeholders’ perceptions of these different types of environmental inequities are rarely studied, though they are crucial for understanding trade-offs between equity dimensions and assessing the social impacts and legitimacy of ES management policies, especially in areas with socio-ecological conflicts.
This study explores environmental inequities perceived by stakeholders in the Maurienne valley (France) regarding three key ES: agricultural production, biodiversity conservation, and outdoor recreation. We conducted 45 semi-structured interviews with ES beneficiaries and managers, focusing on their perceptions of inequities and their causes, including power asymmetries. We used content analysis to identify inequities mentioned in the interviews, as well as perceived winners, losers and underlying mechanisms. We examined how stakeholders’ perceptions varied depending on their scale of influence (i.e. regional, watershed, municipal…) and their sector of activity (e.g., NGOs, public sector, businesses, farmers, etc.), and how they could explain existing conflicts in the Maurienne Valley.
Our analyses reveal that procedural and recognition inequities are more frequently perceived and mentioned than distributive ones. This contrasts with the limited attention given to these dimensions in the environmental justice literature. Recognition and procedural inequities are often linked to interactions between ES, and differing views on which ES should be prioritized. This is particularly evident when stakeholders with different scales of influence hold conflicting preferences – for instance, tourists or NGOs at regional scale often prioritize environmental conservation, while local farmers or representatives tend to favor economic development.
These results highlight the importance of integrating perceptions of environmental inequities in policy design to ensure these policies are truly perceived as sustainable and fair, especially in mountain regions with multiple activities competing for land.

ID: 3.11313

Negotiating the future of pastoralism in shared rural landscapes – reflections from a participatory process in the French Southern Alps

Emilie Crouzat
Couix, Nathalie; Stark, Fabien; Shakura, Imad; Dutilly, Céline; Lasseur, Jacques

Abstract/Description

Since a few decades, social-ecological systems of the French Southern Alps undergo several drivers of change in socio-demographic, political and ecological terms. They turned from an agriculture-based to a tourism-based economy, leading to a diversification of activities at landscape scale. While extensive livestock farming has been a strong pillar of local identity and has traditionally shaped cultural landscapes, its roles are increasingly being questioned with regard to its ability to accommodate other uses of the territory, in particular those related to recreational activities, forest management and biodiversity conservation. In this context, livestock farming becomes a topic of public concern and farmers are facing a diversity of views on ‘what pastoralism should be’.
We present results from a case study carried out in the Southern French Alps as a participatory research that associated over two years an interdisciplinary team of scientists, a community of municipalities and a diversity of local stakeholders who feel concerned by the future of pastoralism in their territory and/or who gets to interact with pastoral uses in the course of their own activities. We hypothesized that considering the multifunctionality of livestock farming and its articulation to other activities is key for strengthening pastoralism and reducing conflicts over land uses. Our research combined individual interviews and collective workshops to elicit the diverse opinions on the current situation and conflicts. It also offered arenas to discuss possible options for better accommodating multiple uses, including pastoralism, in the near future.
Our results highlight the diversity of (possibly conflicting) expectations that are attributed to livestock farming by local actors. They also illustrate multiple ways farmers experiment to deal with these demands, based on how they envision their own work and relationships to their herd, the environment and other land users. We present different strategies collectively identified by local stakeholders that could be operationalized to foster a novel equilibrium among activities in the future, including avoidance strategies over time and space. We discuss the strengths and limits of our approach in terms of participation and ability to address questions related to local identity and balance between activities.

ID: 3.11614

Historical perspective continue shaping Peruvian Andean pastoralists’ territories, livelihoods and markets

Cecilia Turin

Abstract/Description

The high Andean pastoralists, mainly those who raise camelids, are unable to overcome the historical legacy left not only by the Spanish colony, but above all by British mercantilism. The commercial structure they currently employ continues reproducing the two main commercial legacies, Spanish colonialism and British mercantilism, and it is this that keeps them underdeveloped. The aim of this study is to understand and making visible the impacts of both types of markets from a historical perspective in order to explain the current situation. This is in order to identify potential alternatives to propose improvements in agricultural and rural development policies. The methodology employed is an archival study, using a database collected by a historical approach project that seeks to understand the influence of the introduction of European livestock on the American continent.

ID: 3.12222

Nemesis of Coexistence: Politics, and the Perpetual Dilemma of Brown Bear Management in Romania

Mihai I. Pop
Keresztesi, Agnes; Manolache, Steluța; Szep, Robert

Abstract/Description

Social perceptions of interactions with brown bears are dynamic, constantly being constructed and deconstructed under the influence of cultural and governance systems. Values, perceptions, and narratives play a crucial role in shaping wildlife policies and governance systems, which, in turn, influence societal behaviors toward bears. But what happens when policies are absent? Are political decisions alone sufficient? We argue that in Romania, 40 years of policy absence coupled with heavy political intervention have always led to changes in perceptions and narratives. However, in the long term, social memory resets itself, contributing to a cycle of unresolved problems. Using historical and contemporary case studies—particularly from Covasna County—the study reveals how governmental decision-making, centralized and inconsistent, has shaped bear management practices over time. The lack of a coherent, data-driven approach has contributed to a cycle of reactive measures, rather than sustainable, long-term personalised strategies. Interviews conducted with policymakers, researchers, and wildlife managers further illustrate the complexity of managing coexistence and the fragility of decision-making processes. A core argument is that successful coexistence requires a systematic, adaptive approach grounded in collaboration, compromise, and local community engagement. Without strong policies, political intervention alone cannot resolve conflicts, and the historical cycle of uncertainty and unresolved issues is bound to persist.

ID: 3.12875

Envisioning utopia? Epistemologies of socio-ecological transformation

Jutta Kister
Dorn, Felix; Hafner, Robert

Abstract/Description

In this presentation, we aim at taking a closer look at the strains of argumentation that encompass the term socio-ecological transformation contouring the epistemologies of the concept. Scholars are using it in various ways, e.g., as a strategy to overcome multiple crises by aiming towards a common good but also as an analytical tool. This raises the question, how we as scholars can make use of these epistemologies for researching situated spatial dynamics? Society is heading towards an uncertain future, which opens up a range of directions. If the aim – the desirable future – is a matter of negotiation among different actors and groups, then conflicts can be seen as frictions among differing visions and imaginations of the future. We aim at discussing these epistemologies and the roles of researchers can assume in them.

ID: 3.13212

Who belongs in the Bow Valley? Teasing out tensions in Canadian Rocky Mountain Narratives

Lauren Kepkiewicz

Abstract/Description

This presentation examines competing ways that Canadian Rocky Mountain communities are understood, imagined, and experienced. I argue that these competing narratives make visible the often racist, classist, and colonial understandings of who belongs in these Canadian Rocky Mountain geographies. Drawing from a community-based research project based in the Bow Valley in Canada’s Rocky Mountains, I discuss three tensions that are often not visible in mainstream narratives about these communities. First, while Bow Valley communities, including Banff and Lake Louise, are widely known as world-class tourist destinations with high-end hotels, famous ski hills and expensive restaurants, the community members who staff these industries often cannot afford to feed and house themselves. Second, while popular and local narratives often celebrate mountain sports such as climbing, mountaineering, and skiing as the primary way that people interact with mountains, cultural communities who are at the forefront of addressing social inequities are not considered to be or celebrated as part of mountain culture. Third, while municipalities and conservation groups enact policies and programs that discourage, and in some cases make illegal, food provisioning practices, community members underline the need to break down narratives that pit people’s ability to provision food against the wellbeing of wildlife. In teasing out these competing understandings of how people relate to and build a sense of belonging within mountain geographies, this research aims to challenge popular ideas of what constitutes a “mountain person” in the Canadian Rocky Mountains. I argue that doing so is a necessary part of creating transformative change that addresses the intersection of social and ecological crises in these communities. This research contributes to the development of Canadian mountain studies, where reports such as the Canadian Mountain Assessment (McDowell et al., 2023) devote important attention to the cultural and economic contributions of mountain guides, for example, while overlooking the Temporary Foreign Workers who form the backbone of the service industry. This research also echoes calls for community-driven, transdisciplinary research (ie. Balzarini et al., 2022) to build a mountain studies field that reflects the diversity, complexity, and needs of the mountain communities in which we live and work.